Prostitution or Capitalism? Virginity on the Auction Block

This week, a 22 year old student in San Diego is auctioning her virginity. Predictably, it has sparked a firestorm on teh intarweb regarding morality.

“Maybe this is the conservative in me coming out, but this seems so wrong,” wrote one blogger, Mike. “Isn’t this prostitution?”

“I must say I feel sad for the future of our society,” said Mike from Montclair State University in New Jersey.

Is it prostitution? Yes. Yes, it is. Rather predictably, it doesn’t bother me. Here’s the thing: prostitution should never have been a crime. Women (and men) are offering services for money. Some people are willing to pay for those services. The fact of the matter is….it’s their bodies. They’re the only ones who should have a say as to whether they sell it or not. I do wonder if there would be quite the black market trade for sex slaves were prostitution legal.

Let’s look at Nevada. Those women (and men)* have health insurance, are clean, are not mistreated, are in many cases earning money to put themselves through school….all legally.

Prostitution law is essentially legislating morality. Now…don’t get me wrong. Prostitution is not something I want my daughter to see as the best way of putting one’s self through school. But we’re not doing ourselves or those women any favors by criminalizing it. And from what I can tell, it hasn’t reduced the numbers significantly. Making the fines stiffer, imposing tougher sentences….hell, even the guy renowned for prosecuting hookers frequented them. And yet we continue to pretend that an adult willingly selling their body^ is somehow a criminal. I realize this may be a bit abstract, but … isn’t there a point where we all end up trading sex for something we want? If we were really honest with ourselves, I’m not sure how many people would be able to say they didn’t trade sex for something or something for sex. Security, marriage, a car, hell… I’ve even heard coworkers talk about giving their husbands blowjobs to get them to do various things around the house. How is that NOT trading sex for a payoff?

We like to pretend that sex is always (or should be) some pure thing, some high emotional transaction, a mingling of souls. When the fact of the matter is….we are human beings. Mammals. Animals. And we are at our most animalistic during sex. An orgasm isn’t a holy union. It’s a biological function. That happens to feel good. And I do not say this to denigrate it. I say this because I think people have turned sex into a false idol. We’ve put it on a pedestal and changed it into a mold it doesn’t fit. Hence all the neurosis. Sex is sex. It feels good, and we like it. But like most things, it’s been totally mangled and demonized by both religion and society.

Let the girl do whatever the hell she wants with her body. If someone finds worth in what she has to sell and she’s examined her innermost self and is okay with the repercussions….so be it. This is America. Where we believe we are free to live our lives as we like. Leave her the hell alone already.

*sorry I keep putting (and men) in parenthases. But I don’t see men prostituting themselves in nearly the numbers that women do. Not sure why that is. On the other hand…I’ve seen the business world. We’re all someone’s whore at the end of the day….

^ I am not talking about those who are forced into the sex slave industry or underaged or coerced people. Obviously, that’s another kettle of fish. I’m only addressing those who choose to do so of their own volition.


3 responses to “Prostitution or Capitalism? Virginity on the Auction Block

  1. Pingback: Prostitution or Capitalism? Virginity on the Auction Block « Skepfeeds-The Best Skeptic blogs of the day

  2. I totally agree and have thought of all that before.

    I especially like the part about how most people trade sex for something. I have remarked to my husband several times that marriage is just legal prostitution among two people because many times when I ask him to do something he requests sex in exchange.

    And I do know woman that will “please” their husbands to convince them to buy them things or take them on vacations and such.

    All just variations of prostitution.
    (for the record…my husband never wins his argument for sex but I always get what I want, muwahahaha)

  3. HA! See? Hope springs eternal 😛

    Thanks for the comment, Jen.

    We need to get over our idea that sex is somehow inherently bad. It isn’t, but for whatever reason, our automatic response to anything that challenges our impulse control is “it’s bad!” The church then capitalizes on that by adding “evil.” And througout, women (and children) have paid for all of the nonsense that gets spread about sex; whether it’s being drowned in a “dunking chair” or whipped in front of an entire town for being a witch and inciting “lewd dreams” in men (of course, it’s never the man’s fault for not controlling his own thoughts…heaven forFEND a man actually be held accountable!)or constantly being blamed as the responsible party in an extramarital affair (even wives blame the other women. Why do we do that?)… the neurosis about sex is now so deeply rooted it’s going to take generations to get the human race over itself.

    It’s sex. It’s what we do to reproduce. And as a reward system, evolution gifted us with orgasms to make us want to keep doing it. Humans are not the only animals who have sex for pleasure. We’re just the only ones who turn it into a moral failing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s